Illuminating analysis in NAO report

08/09/2017

person photo

Joanne Easterbrook

Senior Partner

The National Audit Office (NAO) study published today, Managing the costs of clinical negligence in trusts, puts forward a clear evidence-based analysis of the challenge facing the NHS and the public purse in dealing with clinical negligence claims.

Certainly, there is much to take stock of, with the cost of claims quadrupling over the last ten years to stand at £1.6bn in 2016 – and predicted to double from that to £3.2bn by 2020-21.

But the report was very clear that this proliferation of claims is not because standards of patient care have been declining.  Rather, the problem is largely due to factors outside the control of Trusts or NHS Resolution.  A significant factor has been the broadening of access to justice and legal service reforms.

As a result, claimant damages and costs have spiralled dramatically – although the proportion of claims where damages are paid remains relatively stable.  Costs as well as numbers of claims have increased.  Over ten years, high value claims damages awards have increased whilst in lower value claims the legal costs exceed the damages awarded in 61% of successful claims and have increased by 533% overall.

On the other side of the equation, legal defence costs have broadly only risen in line with inflation and NHS Resolution’s own costs in dealing with claims has fallen significantly, from £721 per claim in 2006-07 to £414 in 2016-17.

The NAO study shows that NHS Resolution is controlling its own costs effectively and achieves savings for the public purse by contesting unmeritorious or excessive claims.  It has saved an estimated £144m by challenging claimant costs and successfully defended claims where an estimated £1.2bn had been sought in damages.  This excludes reductions in damages claimed in cases where liability has been conceded.

As a law firm that works for NHS Resolution defending it from claims, we are studying the NAO’s report very carefully.  We also welcome the announcement today of new legislation aimed at changing the way in which the personal injury discount rate is set.

What is clear is that there will be no quick solution to stop the rising numbers and costs of claims.  The report notes that limited research has been done to date on the reasons people make claims, as it remains a small proportion of those who have an adverse outcome and this is an area for investigation.  Some policy decisions may need to be taken to ease the problem with a cross-government approach being advocated which balances access to justice and access to health services. 

In the meantime, it will remain a case of defending claims effectively and we will continue to work with NHS Resolution and NHS Trusts to support initiatives aimed at ensuring fair outcomes for all parties.

 

Related Insights

South West Medico-Legal Seminar

by Joanna Lloyd

This half day seminar, aimed at legal, claims, and risk personnel working in health bodies, will provide you with all the information you need to widen your knowledge and get up to update on current hot legal topics in healthcare. We have chosen topics with practical applications in order to provide you with useful advice that can then be shared in your organisation.

Event: Health Technology and Transformation - Risk and Market Issues

by Carlton Sadler

Following the success of our recent event "Health Technology and Transformation – The Regulatory Framework", we decided to run a series of events bringing together industry leaders, regulators and support services working in the digital healthtech industry to identify and address opportunities, and stress factors. Each of the events will be focused on a different thematic area for which we will be joined by specialised speakers Our inaugural event for 2018 will take place at the Bevan Brittan London office on 19th March 2018 and will focus on risk and market issues including a comprehensive industry case study.

Health and Social Care Update - February 2018

by Claire Bentley

Policy and law relevant to those involved in health and social care work.

Bevan Brittan finds Arab market in good health

by Vincent Buscemi

Bevan Brittan was delighted to attend the recent Arab Health conference and exhibition in Dubai. The conference is a major industry event with over 100,000 visitors from 150 countries and more than 4,000 exhibitors.

The transition between Children and Adult Mental Health Services – How can you improve?

by Samantha Minchin

December 2017 saw the Government publish its Green Paper on 'Transforming Children and Young People's Mental Health'. Part of that paper acknowledged that some people require ongoing support into early adulthood after they leave the children and young person's mental health service (CAMHS).

Caring for the health of migrants

by Claire Bentley

The current migration crisis is one of the most urgent global challenges that we face. More people have been forced to leave their homes and countries due to war, violence, exploitation or persecution than at any time in the 70 years that the UNHCR has been in existence.

The General Data Protection Regulations ("GDPR"): A Practical Approach Following Implementation

by Jane Bennett

The European GDPR will come into force in the UK on 25 May 2018, replacing the current Data Protection Act 1998 ("DPA").

Children and Young People's Mental Health: The Vision for Change in Service Provision

by Sumayyah Malna

Suicide is one of the leading causes of death in young people in the UK. Statistics show that there were 922 suicides and probable suicides by people aged under 25 from January 2014 to December 2015.

Keep up to date With Bevan Brittan

What interests you?

About you?